From the Pit to the Promise..
Joseph, Judah, and the Strange Wisdom of God…
When I read Genesis 37, I’m struck by how innocent Joseph appears—and how dark the hearts of his brothers seem..
They see him coming. They recognize him from a distance.
And before he even arrives, they say, “Come now, let us kill him.” (Gen 37:20)
That sentence alone should stop us.
This is not a momentary slip. It’s premeditated hatred. And yet, as the story unfolds, something unexpected happens: Joseph survives, but Judah becomes central to God’s redemptive plan.
That tension invites us to slow down and ask:
What is God doing here?
A Family Fractured by Jealousy
Joseph’s brothers are united in resentment—but divided in conscience.
Reuben wants to rescue Joseph quietly.
Judah wants to remove him profitably.
Others simply want him gone.
No one steps forward to say, “This is wrong.”
Joseph is stripped, thrown into a pit, sold like property, and erased from the family narrative—all while the brothers sit down to eat (Gen 37:25).
Joseph does nothing to deserve this.
And Scripture never suggests that he does.
Reflection:
- Where do we see ourselves in this circle of brothers?
- Are we the ones who actively harm?
- The ones who hesitate but stay silent?
- Or the ones who find a “reasonable” alternative that still avoids righteousness?
Reuben and Judah: Two Responses to Evil
Reuben tries to manage sin without confronting it.
Judah tries to solve the problem without taking responsibility for justice.
Neither approach stops the injustice.
And yet, Scripture is already setting something up.
Reuben fades from the narrative.
Judah does not.
Why?
The Interruption We’d Rather Skip: Genesis 38
Right when Joseph disappears into Egypt, the story abruptly shifts to Judah.
And it’s messy.
Judah compromises.
Judah fails Tamar.
Judah sins sexually.
Judah is exposed publicly.
Then comes one of the most overlooked confessions in Genesis:
“She is more righteous than I.” (Gen 38:26)
This is not self-pity.
This is not excuse-making.
This is repentance.
Judah is not chosen because he is better than Joseph.
He is chosen because he is changed.
Reflection:
- When confronted with our sin, do we defend ourselves—or do we allow truth to break us open?
- Have we underestimated how much God values repentance over reputation?
Judah Learns to Stand in Another’s Place
Years later, in Genesis 44, Judah stands before the same brother he once betrayed—though he doesn’t know it yet.
Benjamin is about to be enslaved.
Jacob would be crushed—again.
And Judah speaks:
“Please let your servant remain instead of the boy.” (Gen 44:33)
This is the same man who once said,
“What profit is it if we kill our brother?”
Now he says,
“Let me take his place.”
This is substitution.
This is transformation.
This is the seed of something far greater.
The Blessing That Explains Everything
On his deathbed, Jacob finally reveals how God has been weaving all of this together:
“The scepter shall not depart from Judah…” (Gen 49:10)
Joseph receives the birthright—fruitfulness, preservation, life.
Judah receives the scepter—rule, kingship, promise.
Later Scripture makes it explicit:
“Judah became strong among his brothers, and a ruler came from him, though the birthright belonged to Joseph.” (1 Chr 5:2)
God did not choose Judah instead of Joseph.
God divided the promise.
Joseph saves God’s people from famine.
Judah’s descendant saves God’s people from sin.
And Then Comes Jesus
Matthew begins his Gospel like this:
“Judah the father of Perez and Zerah, by Tamar…” (Matt 1:3)
Matthew could have hidden that story.
He highlights it.
Why?
Because Jesus does not come from a sanitized family line.
He comes from a line shaped by repentance, brokenness, and grace.
Joseph’s life points to Christ.
Judah’s line brings Christ.
Joseph is betrayed, falsely accused, and yet forgives.
Jesus is betrayed, condemned, and yet redeems.
Judah offers himself for his brother.
Jesus becomes the substitute for us all.
Living With This Story Today
This story asks us uncomfortable questions:
- Do we believe God can redeem our worst chapters?
- Are we more impressed by innocence—or by repentance?
- Do we try to manage sin like Reuben, justify it like Judah once did, or allow God to transform us like Judah later did?
God is not looking for flawless people to carry His purposes.
He is forming redeemed people who know the cost of grace.
A Closing Prayer
Lord God,
You are the God who sees the pit and the palace,
the betrayal and the blessing.
We confess that we often admire Joseph’s righteousness
while quietly fearing Judah’s story—
because Judah’s story looks more like our own.
Thank You that You are not limited by our failures,
and that repentance can reshape destiny.
Teach us not only to avoid sin,
but to confront it honestly,
to take responsibility,
and to learn how to stand in the place of others
with humility and love.
We praise You for Jesus—
the Lion of Judah,
the true Substitute,
the Redeemer who entered our broken family story
to make us whole.
May our lives point to Him.
Amen.
